| Q1 - February 21 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Nominees | Proposed by | Vote Count |
| Resident Evil Remake | Michael Huber | 0 |
| Dark Souls | Bradley Ellis | 1 |
| Metal Gear Solid | Michael Damiani | 10 |
| GoldenEye 007 | Brandon Jones | 1 |
| Mega Man Legends | Kyle Bosman | 1 |
| Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag | Don Casanova | 2 |
| Super Metroid | Daniel Bloodworth | 9 |
| Super Street Fighter II Turbo | Ben Moore | 9 |
| Bloodborne | Ian Hinck | 3 |
| Q2 - May 24 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Nominees | Proposed by | Vote Count |
| Dragon Quest VIII: Journey of the Cursed King | Michael Huber | 5 |
| Sim City 4 | Don Casanova | 1 |
| World of Warcraft | Brandon Jones | 1 |
| The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening DX | Kyle Bosman | 5 |
| Super Mario 64 | Bradley Ellis Michael Damiani |
15 |
| Street Fighter II | Daniel Bloodworth | 14 |
| Valkyria Chronicles | Ben Moore | 1 |
| Castlevania: Symphony of the Night | Ian Hinck | 12 |
| Q3 - August 22 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Nominees | Proposed by | Vote Count |
| Half-Life 2 | Brandon Jones | 5 |
| Doom (2016) | Bradley Ellis | 0 |
| The Last of Us | Michael Huber | 4 |
| Jurassic Park: Operation Genesis | Don Casanova | 2 |
| Final Fantasy IX | Kyle Bosman | 9 |
| Castlevania: Symphony of the Night | Ian Hinck | 11 |
| The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time | Michael Damiani | 16 |
| Xenoblade Chronicles | Ben Moore | 3 |
| Portal | Daniel Bloodworth | 4 |
| Q4 - December 12 | ||
|---|---|---|
| Nominees | Proposed by | Vote Count |
| Streets of Rage 2 | Michael Huber | 4 |
| Super Mario Maker | Don Casanova | 3 |
| Pokémon Red and Blue | Kyle Bosman | 8 |
| Journey | Daniel Bloodworth | 2 |
| Mega Man X | Ben Moore | 7 |
| Grand Theft Auto III | Brandon Jones | 7 |
| The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim | Michael Damiani | 0 |
| Myst | Ian Hinck | 2 |
| Chrono Trigger | Bradley Ellis | 21 |