The Easy Allies Hall of Greats is a quarterly Group Stream Night event in which the Allies vote for the games they deem worthy of being called One of the Greats. These are chosen in a heated debate in which each Ally brings forth a game they believe is a great one, and they have five minutes to present their case to the rest of the Allies, who will then ask the presenter a variety of questions about their game for another five minutes. After every game has been presented, they vote for the games they think should enter the Hall of Greats.
The Allies must vote for three games by giving them 3 points, 2 points, and 1 point respectively, in order of worthiness. Starting on the 4th induction, the voting is made using werehog chips.
The voting must be secret among the Allies, but they must explain to the audience their reasoning behind their votes. After points have been counted, the Allies are able to disclose their votes to each other and discuss them.
If a game gets no points from the Allies other than the person who proposed it, it will be banned from entering the contest for a whole year. Also, starting on the 5th induction, the Allies can no longer vote for the same game they proposed.
The two games with the most points in each induction shall enter the Hall of Greats. Furthermore, only the games that have made it into the Hall of Greats may be called "One of the Greats".
After a game has entered the Hall of Greats, the Allies must do some kind of work related to the game in question, whether it be a full playthrough or something else entirely.
Starting with the 8th induction, alliances between the allies have officially been banned.
*Due to an error on Kyle's part, both Brad and Damiani were allowed to bring Super Mario 64 to the Q2 2017 Hall of Greats Induction #2. They each received separate five minute presentations on the game and handled the cross-examination together.
There was no Hall of Greats for Q4 of 2018 due to time constraints.
Brandon brought World of Warcraft to the Q2 2017 Hall of Greats Induction #2 and it was subsequently banned for a year under the previous ban rules. He would bring WoW for the second time in the Q1 2020 Hall of Greats Induction #12 and receive the most votes of the night.